Closed-loop vs open-loop gift cards: the difference and which one fits you
Gift cards are often described as closed-loop or open-loop. The difference is where the card can be used and who issues it.
Closed-loop cards
A closed-loop card works only within a defined circle: one brand’s stores, one group’s brands or one shopping centre’s stores. The business issues the card itself and the card carries its brand.
Examples:
- a retail chain’s gift card that works in its stores and web shop;
- a shopping centre card that works with the centre’s tenants;
- a spa or clinic gift card for its services.
Open-loop cards
An open-loop card works like a prepaid bank card. It is accepted wherever that card network is accepted, such as Visa or Mastercard. It is issued by a payment institution or bank.
Examples:
- a prepaid Visa or Mastercard gift card;
- some shopping centre cards that are technically bank cards but restricted to the centre’s stores.
Comparison
| Closed-loop | Open-loop | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it works | Your stores or centre | Anywhere the card network is accepted |
| Who issues it | Your business | A payment institution or bank |
| Brand | Yours | The card network’s and the issuer’s |
| Money | Stays in your circle | Can be spent elsewhere |
| Costs | System fee | Plus card and issuing fees |
| Regulation | Simpler | Payment and e-money rules |
| Data | Yours | Partly held by the issuer |
What suits a shopping centre
A shopping centre wants to keep money inside the centre. A closed-loop card does exactly that: the recipient has to come to the centre. An open-loop card can look simpler because it works with any card terminal, but it brings bank card fees, and money can leave the centre unless the card is restricted.
With a closed-loop card the key question is settlement: when a card is sold at the information desk and redeemed in a tenant’s store, the centre must settle with the tenant. A good system produces that report automatically.
What suits a retail chain or service business
Almost always a closed-loop card. The point is that the gift brings the customer to you. The card carries your brand, customer data stays with you and the card works at the till and online.
Summary
If you want the card to bring customers to you, choose closed-loop. Open-loop suits a gift that can be spent anywhere, but then it’s more a payment service than your branded gift card.
On Gifto Platform
Gifto Platform is a closed-loop system. You issue the card and the money stays with you. A card can work in one brand’s stores, across a group or across a whole shopping centre, with reports for settlement between the parties.
See also: how to launch your own gift card programme.